Debate Sparked by Singing Aboard Vande Bharat Express: Joyful Symphony or Public Nuisance?
A recent video posted by the official Southern Railways handle on X has stirred controversy online. It captures a group of women singing the Tamil song ‘Kanmani Anbodu’ by Ilaiyaraaja and A R Rahman aboard the Vande Bharat Express train from Chennai to Mysuru. Wearing ID cards and using their phones for lyrics, these women were described by Southern Railways as creating a “symphony of joy” during their journey. However, the reaction on social media has been mixed, with some users criticizing the act as ‘irritating’ and a ‘public nuisance.’
Critics argue that such behavior disrupts the comfort and peace of other passengers, who expect a quiet environment, especially when paying a premium for travel on the modern, silent-operation train. Comments flooded in, expressing annoyance and suggesting that individuals who want to enjoy music should use headphones or engage in group activities elsewhere. The concern is that promoting such acts might set a precedent for similar disturbances, affecting passengers’ ability to relax or sleep during their journey.
Despite the intent to showcase a joyful moment, the video has sparked a debate on the balance between public expression and maintaining a considerate environment for all passengers. The discussion raises questions about the appropriateness of such activities in shared public spaces, and whether rail authorities should regulate them to ensure a pleasant experience for everyone on board.
Pic Courtesy: google/ images are subject to copyright
